top of page
Search

This rehab idea needs to die.

4 days ago
2 min read

The idea that you can simply strengthen a painful area and expect the pain to go away needs to die.


You know the routine. Someone has back pain, so many therapists and even their friends suggest for them to strengthen their core. Their knee hurts, so they should strengthen their quads. Their shoulder hurts, so out comes the band for rotator cuff exercises. This has been repeated so often, that “it needs to be stronger” has become an explanation we barely question.


But when did pain become proof of weakness? And when a muscle isn’t firing the way we expect, why are we so quick to assume that’s what caused the pain? Maybe the pain changed how that muscle works.


In fact this is well established neuroscience, and we’ve had this information for decades. In 2003, Hodges and colleagues showed that experimentally induced muscle pain changed anticipatory trunk muscle activity. Nobody had to spend six weeks getting weaker first. Introducing pain was enough to change how those muscles were recruited. Hodges et al., 2003


That matters and it means the altered muscle activity you’re looking at could be a response to pain. You can’t just point to it, call it the problem, and assume strengthening will sort it out.


Sensory input shapes motor output. Your nervous system uses information from your body to organize movement, and pain can change that organization. Hodges and Tucker describe how activity can shift within and between muscles, proposing that these changes can serve a protective purpose. The response varies from person to person and task to task. Hodges and Tucker, 2011


And if you’ve ever heard us say that “sensory trumps motor…this is what we mean. You can’t understand what a muscle is doing while ignoring the information influencing it. That doesn’t mean sensory treatment must always come first. It means “make it stronger” is nowhere near a complete explanation.


And I can already hear the pushback…“But my patients get better with strengthening.”


Good and you keep using what helps. But someone improving with strengthening doesn’t prove they were in pain because they were weak. It also doesn’t prove that gaining strength was what reduced their pain. The improvement can be real while the explanation needs work.


I’m pushing back on how confidently we turn “this hurts” into “this is weak.” Those are different findings, and we need to stop treating them as interchangeable.


Build strength, progress load, but just be willing to question the story you’re telling the person in front of you. If that story begins and ends with “you need to get stronger,” something is amiss in your clinical reasoning.


Til next week…ask yourself if the exercises you’re giving address a genuine strength deficit, or if they’re just your go-to when you don’t know what else to do with someone’s pain.


Sherry


 
 
bottom of page